Notice: I'm an affiliate for Amazon as well as other companies. Any links in this article may be affiliate links. I always appreciate it if you purchase something using my affiliate links. Doing so helps me to raise a little extra money that pays for the costs of running this site. And it allows me to continue bringing you quality content, all without costing you a thing! Thanks!
So, now that you’re eating real foods, you’ve realized that you can’t really use store bought powdered sugar from the store shelves anymore, simply because it is made with white refined sugar. When this thought crossed my mind, I began trying to come up with acceptable substitutes. I love using powdered sugar on occasion in frosting recipes and I absolutely love making peanut butter balls for the holidays each year. But both of those things use…..you guessed it, powdered sugar.
So I had some Sucanat in the pantry and tried grinding some in a coffee grinder, and guess what? IT WORKED!
I had previously tried to grind the sugar using my mini food processor and it just didn’t work. Not enough power, I guess. But the coffee grinder worked well and very quickly! Now, because of the size of the coffee grinder, you will need to do several batches in order to get enough of the powdered sugar to use for a batch of frosting. But I was able to grind down one batch of sugar in about 20 seconds.
Also, be aware that there will be a taste difference when using these powdered sugars, especially if you use Sucanat. Sucanat has a stronger, brown sugar taste that may not be appealing to you. It really is a personal preference. If making a caramel flavored drizzle, icing or frosting, then the brown sugar taste of the Sucanat is absolutely perfect!
There is also a difference in the color. The Sucanat based powdered sugar is a deeper tan color, and may not do well with natural food colorings. Just be aware!
Also be aware that you should use this powdered sugar in moderation. I only use this recipe a few times a year, typically for foods that I am making for special occasions. But it works well for those things.